🎉 Giảm 20% cho đơn hàng đầu tiên!✦🚚 Miễn phí vận chuyển cho đơn trên 500.000₫✦⚡ Flash Sale — Số lượng có hạn!✦🎁 Quà tặng kèm cho đơn từ 1.000.000₫✦🎉 Giảm 20% cho đơn hàng đầu tiên!✦🚚 Miễn phí vận chuyển cho đơn trên 500.000₫✦⚡ Flash Sale — Số lượng có hạn!✦🎁 Quà tặng kèm cho đơn từ 1.000.000₫✦
First Director Criminally Tried in Vietnam for Using Unlicensed Software in His Own Company
Quay lại Blog

First Director Criminally Tried in Vietnam for Using Unlicensed Software in His Own Company

19 tháng 11, 20267 phút đọcVũ Khôi
English
#English#Khởi nghiệp & Kinh doanh
Vũ Khôi

Vũ Khôi

Tác giả tại Wotech Electronics Blog

Photo of the decision to bring the case to first-instance trial by the People's Court of Region 1 - Nghe An, No. 377/2026/QĐXXST-HS

First Director Criminally Tried in Vietnam for Using Unlicensed Software in His Own Company

No selling pirated software, no distributing cracked software — only using software to run his own company's operations. So why was the director still brought to criminal trial? On 17/11/2026, the People's Court of Region 1 – Nghe An held a first-instance trial of Mr. Lương Ngọc Thành, Director of Nhà Thoáng Consulting and Construction Co., Ltd., for the crime of "Infringement of copyright and related rights" under Article 225 of the Criminal Code. That is the content of a post by Phạm Duy Khuông (18/11/2026). In the case, ASL LAW represented three rights holders of the Chaos technology group — CHAOS Germany, CHAOS Bulgaria, CHAOS Czech Republic — concerning the software V-Ray, Corona, and Chaos Vantage. All facts, figures, and legal views in this article follow the post and have not been independently verified by Wotech.

Quick answer: According to the post, this is the first case in Vietnam of a company director being criminally tried for using unlicensed software to serve his own company's business operations. The case involved 13 software installations on 7 computers — 5 V-Ray, 4 Corona, and 4 Chaos Vantage. On 11/08/2026, the Criminal Investigation Agency of Nghe An Provincial Police issued a decision to prosecute the criminal case; on 17/11/2026, the People's Court of Region 1 – Nghe An held the first-instance trial. At the end of the trial, the Court imposed a penalty on the defendant, while considering remediation of damages for the software owners and ordering the surrender of money determined to relate to contracts performed using unlicensed software. The post stresses three points companies should remember: foreign software not registered for copyright in Vietnam is still protected under the Berne Convention; a director who did not install the software himself is not automatically exempt from liability; and money earned from contracts performed with unlicensed software was also confiscated.

Article 225 of the Criminal Code is the provision on the crime of "Infringement of copyright and related rights" — according to the post, the basis for prosecution in the Nghe An case.

How does the Nghe An case differ from the Microsoft software case in Phu Tho?

According to the post, in June 2026, Phu Tho Provincial Police prosecuted a case involving the illegal installation and activation of Windows and Microsoft Office software on computers before supplying them to the market; by July 2026, 5 defendants had been prosecuted, including company directors. The difference in the Nghe An case is that the company did not trade in or distribute illegal software — the software was used directly in the company's own design and construction work. If the Phu Tho case concerned supplying computers installed with illegal software, the Nghe An case raises criminal risk for the company itself using software to perform work for clients.

From 7 computers and 13 installations to a criminal case: how was the technical evidence verified?

According to the post, the case involved 13 software installations on 7 computers: 5 V-Ray, 4 Corona, and 4 Chaos Vantage. Even before prosecution, ASL LAW coordinated with Chaos to collect, compile, and analyze technical data, cross-checking information, licensing status, and signs of unlicensed use. The rights holder then filed a request for handling, provided ownership documentation, and cooperated in explaining technical and legal issues for the authorities to verify. On 11/08/2026, the Criminal Investigation Agency of Nghe An Provincial Police issued a decision to prosecute the criminal case.

How were damages determined: does 13 installations mean the price of 13 licenses?

According to the post, this is an important issue in resolving the case. A distinction must be made between the commercial price of a software license, the actual damage with a legal basis, and the value of a remediation plan accepted by the rights holder. Another notable point is that money arising from contracts the company performed using unlicensed software was also confiscated. At the end of the trial, the Court imposed a penalty on the defendant, while considering remediation of damages for the software owners and ordering the surrender of money determined to relate to contracts performed using unlicensed software.

Is foreign software not registered for copyright in Vietnam protected?

According to the post, under the automatic protection principle of the Berne Convention and related international treaties, a computer program that meets the conditions is protected by copyright in Vietnam without being required to register copyright in Vietnam first. Therefore, companies should not assume that software from a foreign company, not registered for copyright in Vietnam, can be freely copied or used without a license.

If IT staff installed the software themselves, is the director liable?

According to the post, this is also an issue the case raises for corporate governance. A director who did not directly perform the installation is not automatically exempt from liability. One of the most common excuses when companies are inspected is to always blame the employee who installed it, claiming the director did not know. The Nghe An case shows this risk is not limited to businesses specializing in trading, copying, or distributing illegal software.

Frequently asked questions

1. Who was tried in the Nghe An case, and for what crime? According to the post, on 17/11/2026 the People's Court of Region 1 – Nghe An held a first-instance trial of Mr. Lương Ngọc Thành, Director of Nhà Thoáng Consulting and Construction Co., Ltd., for "Infringement of copyright and related rights" under Article 225 of the Criminal Code.

2. How much unlicensed software was involved? According to the post: 13 installations on 7 computers — 5 V-Ray, 4 Corona, and 4 Chaos Vantage, belonging to three rights holders of the Chaos group (Germany, Bulgaria, Czech Republic).

3. How does this differ from the Microsoft case in Phu Tho? According to the post, the Phu Tho case involved installing illegal software on computers before supplying them to the market; the Nghe An case involved a company using unlicensed software in its own design and construction work.

4. Is foreign software not registered in Vietnam protected? According to the post, yes — under the Berne Convention's automatic protection principle, a qualifying computer program is protected by copyright in Vietnam without prior registration in Vietnam.

5. Does a director who did not install the software escape liability? According to the post, not automatically — a director who did not directly install the software is not automatically exempt from liability; blaming staff is a common response during inspections but does not eliminate the risk.

Source: post by Phạm Duy Khuông (18/11/2026) about the case in which ASL LAW represented the rights holders of the Chaos group; the post states it was published with Chaos's consent. All facts, figures, and legal views in this article follow the post and have not been independently verified by Wotech.